The hardest thing about writing this blog is coming up with my topic. When I think about an intervention I think about persuasion. Theres so many persuasive pieces out there it can’t be that hard to think of one! I asked myself what is one of the biggest “persuasion campaigns” on television and my first thought was anti-smoking campaigns. Millions of dollars are spent every year on commercials and magazine advertisements to try and convince people to quit smoking. I would even guess that a comparable if not greater amount of money is spent trying to convince people to quit smoking than is spent trying to market and sell cigarettes. I can think of no other market that just as much money is spent trying to prevent purchases as is spent trying to encourage purposes.
This really makes for an interesting scenario. When I thought about how much money is spent trying to market both these options (smoking and quitting smoking) I started to wonder. Are they effective? And which one is more effective? I found a study that stated that the source of anti smoking ads influences their effectiveness. So for instance, ads funded by states or private foundations are found to be the most effective. This leads me to believe that it matters to people how credible the intervener is. This goes along with Aristotle’s theory of persuasion that the ethos, or ethical appeal of the speaker is important to the audience. So no matter how persuasive the advertisement is, it may not encourage change if the person the ad is directed at does not think the source is credible.
I also found an article that discussed a study of how effective the amount of anti-smoking ads were. As the number of ads in a given area increased, the number of smokers decreased. This was true for all up to a certain amount of ads, once there was too many ads, the amount of smokers actually started to increased. This led the researchers to believe that after a certain amount the viewers started to tune out the ads. The intervention was not effective for them because they were not using all of their senses and they abstracted in their environment to form sensory and symbolic categories, they blocked out these ads.
I am going to work with a partner for the paper. We have decided to write about an advertising campaign for our topic. I think this is a really good thing for both of us because we are PR majors and this is something were both interested in. We are meeting after class on Tuesday to write the proposal paper so we can get a little more information in class about what is expected. After writing this blog post I think it might be interesting to write about anti-smoking commercials for my paper. There is certainly a wide range of options to choose from and lots of information about it. I am going to do some research on it and see if it would be feasible to write my paper on this subject.
No comments:
Post a Comment