Tuesday, March 25, 2014

Symbolically Categorizing a Relationship

Although many of these concepts were discussed much earlier in the semester, an intervention occurred this week that made me think of many RSI terms in the early chapters of the book. My roommate Brittany has been friends with our neighbor Chris for the past year. They are very close and do most everything together and my roommates and I have always known that Chris has had feelings for Brittany. Because they had named their relationship as a friendship early on, this name reduced the uncertainty their relationship would experience should he decide to admit his feelings. Well, after a year the name and expectations associated with a friendship was no longer a better alternative for Chris than the uncertainty he would feel by renaming the relationship. This week Chris decided to symbolically categorize their relationship from a friendship to a romantic relationship. 

When we give names to experiences we create expectations. Brittany automatically filed every interaction with Chris into the friendship category because she used this name to give a sense of order in her life. Because Chris was no longer satisfied with symbolically categorizing their relationship as a friendship he advocated his need for Brittany to become his girlfriend. Chris threatened their friendship by sharing his feelings with her and highlighting anomalies in their relationship that didn’t fit into typical expectations of a friendship. He brought up things such as the romantic chemistry they had together and the amount of time they spend with each other and explained how these criterial attributes aligned more with expectations of a romantic relationship. 

Naming reduced uncertainty for Brittany. When Chris admitted his feelings for her and advocated his needs, Brittany was very confused and overwhelmed because she no longer knew how to symbolically categorize their relationship. I think what helped Brittany to regain a sense of order was when Chris explained that they needed to rename their relationship because his feelings (and he hoped hers’ as well) no longer fit into the category of “friendship”. After Chris tried to persuade Brittany to be his girlfriend the way she viewed their experiences no longer matched up with her expectations of a friendship. This made the key difference in how the experience is symbolically categorized. They decided to rename the relationship from friendship to romantic relationship and shift the criterial attributes, thereby redefining the relationship. Once Brittany realized that the actual relationship wasn’t changing, just how she was making sense of it was changing, I think her decision became a little easier. Maybe if she had been familiar with the RSI model this decision would have been a lot easier for her!

This week I met with my partner to write an outline for our paper. We came up with a number of topics to discuss and I think we have a solid foundation for our paper. While discussing some things to write about we were talking about how the CDC campaign is an example of an attention shift in the RSI model, what we weren’t sure about was if it was only an attention shift or is everything an example of power and need  shifts as well...? Other than that I think I understand everything I need to do for my paper and how to describe it using RSI terms. 

Tuesday, March 4, 2014

PR campaigns and RSI critiques

My interest has always been in Public Relations. It is what I am majoring in and it is what I want to do as a career. When reading chapter 5, the steps of an RSI critique reminded me of the RACE process we practice as PR professionals. The RACE acronym stands for research, action, communication, evaluation. This is very similar to the RSI model critique of the pre-analysis, analysis, and post-analysis process. When developing a successful PR campaign, you must first ask, “What will make people interested in this?” Much like the pre-analysis stage of naming the social intervention, to begin enacting the role of RSI critic you must first choose an intervention to analyze. Once you figure out what people are interested in you must figure out how it relates to social change. Maybe skin cancer has become a big issue lately and a sunscreen company wants to take advantage of this, then you must figure out what to emphasize. In PR usually an event or a celebrity endorser helps to draw people to the cause. 

Once you have an idea, you begin to collect data about the intervention, or research as it is referred to in the public relations (PR) process. Or as it is stated in the RSI model, “How have other scholars studied my topic?” Research allows PR professionals to see where other campaigns have gone wrong, what demographic is most interested in this product, and what objectives will best help them meet their goals of improving interaction between the company and its publics. This is where the strategies, tactics, and maneuvers of the RSI critic come into play with the “action” part of the PR process. You must locate the rhetorical artifacts that communicate the interveners intentions to determine if your objective is accessible. 

In PR, after we review the data or research and determine the communication process that will most effectively communicate our message we put it into action. In the RSI critique model, we must decide what social system to emphasize in our research. So by abstracting from experience we must decide what people will relate to the intervention and we do this for both processes. As part of enacting the role of RSI critic, the questions we are given to ask ourselves such as, “How will I share my interpretation with others?” or “Who is the audience for my analysis?” are similar to questions we as PR professionals ask ourselves when evaluating a successful campaign. Although the steps do not match up exactly the steps for developing a PR campaign are very similar to the RSI model critique of pre-analysis, analysis, and post-analysis processes.

I think I am starting to understand the terms a little more now. I think because the terms are starting to repeat more and as I begin to see them again and again in the readings they are starting to become more familiar. As they are becoming more familiar, I am starting to get a better idea of what RSI topics I can focus on in my paper. From my research I am going to come up with 10 or so ideas with my partner to cover in our paper. From these ideas will be main topics or paragraphs covered in the essay. I think this will be a good alternative to an outline and help us get a good start.