Tuesday, May 6, 2014

Final Blog Post

As I learn more about interventions and the RSI model I can’t help but question if I am an effective intervener. Not that I think that at 21 I should be well on my way to bringing about social change, but I still have a hard time convincing my roommate to take out the trash. This course has helped to show me that in order to be a more effective intervener I need to appeal to a person’s sense of need, power, or attention. I found it to be very interesting that peoples’ motivations behind the decisions they make come down to these three simple things. 
When I took a moment to think about my personal motivations, I was unable to find a situation that my underlying reasoning did not fall into one of these three categories. In order to be a more effective intervener I have started applying RSI concepts to my own life. A very basic example, instead of constantly nagging my roommate to take out the trash, I thought about how much she is afraid of germs and uncleanliness. I attempted to shift her attention by pointing out that when she does’t take out the trash, the food spoils and germs multiply creating an unpleasant smell. This tactic was much more effective, so the knowledge and skills I learned in this course are already becoming useful to me!
I thought the paper was the most helpful way for me to learn about interpersonal and social intervention. Personally, I found the quizzes to be the least helpful. I really struggled with having to recall words from the readings and put them into fill in the blank format questions. I learn best by doing and being interactive, by talking through RSI concepts with Justin and researching interventions I was able to best understand these topics. As the semester went on and I became more comfortable with the readings and I progressed in my paper, I felt that my understanding of RSI concepts became much broader. 
My views of interpersonal and social intervention have definitely changed as a result of this course because prior to January I could not have told you what the RSI model was! My understanding has increased in regards to understanding of what an intervention is and what are ways to go about creating social change. My view of interpersonal communication has changed because I now look to the RSI model to try and decipher peoples motivations and almost look to it as a means of persuasion. I also find it very useful in situations when I don’t understand why a person is doing something. By focusing on need, power, or attention I am able to find the basic reasoning behind the action. 
As stated earlier, I am already finding ways to make the RSI model useful in my own experiences. I plan to go into Public Relations, in this field I will constantly be in situations where I have to use my interpersonal communication skills to further a clients agenda. Specifically referring to the RSI model, it is important to understand the factors that result in social change to create a successful intervention. Public relations is essentially one big intervention! I wrote in one of my blogs a comparison of the RACE model to the RSI model and already I have seen so many similarities between the two models. Overall, I enjoyed this course and thought the content was thoroughly interesting. I have already found the RSI model to be useful and have begun applying concepts to my life. 

Wednesday, April 23, 2014

The 5 Love Languages of Interventions


Although I have not read the book, lately I have been looking into the Five Love Languages. I took the online quiz and wandered around their website for a bit, I found the concept very interesting. They are attempting to shift the current template from “all people accept love in the same way” to “people need to receive love in different ways”. The quiz I took was about 25 questions that asked me things such as, “Would you rather receive a present on your birthday or a card filled with personal thoughts?” When I think of a person’s birthday, I typically only consider recognizing them in some way, whether it be taking them to dinner, buying them a gift, or simply posting on their Facebook wall. I never considered the idea that people want to be recognized and receive love in different ways. 

This group features anomalies in the template that all people accept love in the same way by emphasizing different forms of receiving love and separating them into categories. There are five “love languages” which are: gift of time, acts of service, words of affirmation, gifts and physical touch. When a person takes the online quiz they are quickly and easily able to see what category (or categories) of love languages they respond the best too. I think this is a successful way to look at communication in relationships. Just from viewing the website, the company was able to shift my expectations from the idea that every way I receive love is the same to different ways of receiving love are more important to me than others. 

This week I received my first draft of my paper back and I am preparing for my Intervention Presentation. I am pleased with the progress I have made so far and I think my final draft will be much clearer and more concise than my first draft. I had a few organizational issues that I think were addressed during office hours today. I need to focus on deleting repetitive information and relating my information to the RSI model. I need to rearrange my paper and make it flow better but I think with a little reworking that shouldn’t be an issue.


I am going to finish my final draft alone. I started off this semester working with a partner and it did not go as well as I hoped. I believe in collaboration, I think that it improves the creative process and allows for new ideas to flourish. However, if one person is not putting in the same amount of effort it really just makes for more work for the other person. I think it was a good experience for me, I have never encountered a group project situation where I ran in to these types of issues. I think it helped me to understand that people have different styles and timelines for writing papers and everyone works differently. I am happy that I am finishing this paper alone because of the position I was put it. I think I will be much more productive if I do not have to constantly try to get information from another person. 

Thursday, April 17, 2014

Intervention for Real Beauty

One thing that I miss about being at home with my parents is the multitude of amenities that I, as a poor college student, cannot afford. One such amenity is TiVo. I really epitomize the attitudes of my generation when I say that it’s quite annoying to have to watch commercials. One result of taking this course and watching so many commercials lately is that I am able to connect certain advertisements and campaigns with concepts in the RSI intervention model. One commercial that sticks out in my mind is the Dove campaign for real beauty, which I believe someone in our class is also analyzing for his or her paper. This campaign advocates the need for society to accept women the way they are, and that all women are beautiful regardless of race, age or body type. 

The campaign attempts to shift from the current template of societies views that women are only beautiful if they look like models or a barbie. They want to shift the template that all women are beautiful as shown by the different ages, races, and body types shown in the commercial. The campaign features anomalies in the template that women are the most beautiful if they are ‘young, thin, and blonde’ by featuring women that are beautiful that do not fit into this stereotype. They promote the idea that inner beauty and self confidence are the most important aspects of beauty, not typical societal idea that only one body type is beautiful. 

I have about eleven pages done on my Critical Analysis paper.  I am very satisfied with the direction the paper is taking. I think I have adequately covered all of the sections that are listed on the rubric, now I am just trying to improve upon the concepts I have already covered. Most importantly, I think this paper has really taught me how to utilize the RSI model in the real world. I find myself using RSI concepts now in my everyday thoughts to analyze situations. I find this to be a vast improvement because my number one concern at the beginning of the semester was that I had no idea what all the terms in the book meant. I was wondering if I would ever make sense of them! 


I have actually really enjoyed writing this paper, I think it was very important to pick a topic that I had a personal interest in. If I could do it again I probably would not choose to do this as a group project. I think its very difficult to divide up the work between two people for a research paper. Students have different writing styles and place different priorities higher than other students do. I think the most helpful thing was reading chapter five and structuring my paper exactly as it is stated in the book. Also, it was very helpful to me to know the due dates for this paper for the entire semester. I am more comfortable completing projects when I am able to set up a time table to complete them early on. 

Wednesday, April 2, 2014

Overlapping Theories

As a recent transfer to JMU I am in a number of different introductory SCOM courses and I often find myself being exposed to a number of different communication theories. I find it fascinating that these theories overlap in so many different subject areas within the field of communication. One recent overlap I came across was naming and expectations within the RSI model also occurring in Symbolic Interactionism. Symbolic Interactionism is the ongoing use of language and gestures in anticipation of how others will respond. It was created by George Herbert Mead  and he believed that our thoughts and the wider community we live in are created through communication. The responses we give can be verbal or non-verbal and they are delivered in expectation of how the original speaker will react. This continuing process creates a conversation. This is much like the idea in the RSI model that when we give names to experiences we create expectations. The goal of Symbolic Interactionism is to understand how humans, through interaction with one another, create symbolic worlds or “reality”, and meaning is the construction of social reality. The RSI concept of Ideology is similar to this in the sense that it is a subordinate name for a comprehensive experience that is the result of symbolically categorizing an experience. 

Symbolic Interaction explores the “Interplay between self and society and argues that people act towards others on the basis of meaning they assign to them.” (Griffin, p. 55) Meaning arises out of the social interaction that people have with each other, it is negotiated through the use of language. This is a foundational principle of interventions, we are constantly negotiating new names for things. Humans have a need for a sense of order, and to see a meaningful world. Naming reduces uncertainty and helps us to symbolically categorize experiences. It is the way we interpret the world. We understand things based on the names we give them, such as doctor or mother. The RSI model and Symbolic Interactionism both helps us to understand how meaning, language, and thinking are closely interconnected we are able to understand who we are.

After writing the outline for the paper I researched some of the topics we came up with and I have about eight sources so far. I think we have a solid foundation and enough ideas to cover roughly 15 pages. I have begun writing and we have about 6 pages completed thus far. We have written an introduction and description of the intervention, discussed our personal interest in the intervention, and have begun to discuss the strategies, tactics and maneuvers the CDC uses to shift people’s attention to the damage it does to your health. I think the rest of the paper will be discussing RSI approaches and then summarizing the knowledge gained from the analysis. 

I’m going to talk about the ideology of smoking and how it has been renamed as “bad” over time, using examples of how smoking used to be considered healthy and recommended by doctors. I want to show how the CDC is using these commercials to shift our attention by featuring anomalies in our perceptions of smoking (all the people that have serious diseases and are dying as a result of smoking.) I plan to discuss how they are featuring anomalies by stating and reviewing all of the strategies, tactics, and maneuvers the CDC is using. I also want to go over what are people’s expectations of smoking and how these commercials violate our expectations. While I discuss my personal interest in this RSI intervention I think it would be a good tie in to talk about people who attribute quitting to the CDC campaign and talk about its effectiveness. 


Reference:

Griffin, Emory A. A First Look at Communication. 8th ed. New York: McGraw Hill, 2012. Print.

Tuesday, March 25, 2014

Symbolically Categorizing a Relationship

Although many of these concepts were discussed much earlier in the semester, an intervention occurred this week that made me think of many RSI terms in the early chapters of the book. My roommate Brittany has been friends with our neighbor Chris for the past year. They are very close and do most everything together and my roommates and I have always known that Chris has had feelings for Brittany. Because they had named their relationship as a friendship early on, this name reduced the uncertainty their relationship would experience should he decide to admit his feelings. Well, after a year the name and expectations associated with a friendship was no longer a better alternative for Chris than the uncertainty he would feel by renaming the relationship. This week Chris decided to symbolically categorize their relationship from a friendship to a romantic relationship. 

When we give names to experiences we create expectations. Brittany automatically filed every interaction with Chris into the friendship category because she used this name to give a sense of order in her life. Because Chris was no longer satisfied with symbolically categorizing their relationship as a friendship he advocated his need for Brittany to become his girlfriend. Chris threatened their friendship by sharing his feelings with her and highlighting anomalies in their relationship that didn’t fit into typical expectations of a friendship. He brought up things such as the romantic chemistry they had together and the amount of time they spend with each other and explained how these criterial attributes aligned more with expectations of a romantic relationship. 

Naming reduced uncertainty for Brittany. When Chris admitted his feelings for her and advocated his needs, Brittany was very confused and overwhelmed because she no longer knew how to symbolically categorize their relationship. I think what helped Brittany to regain a sense of order was when Chris explained that they needed to rename their relationship because his feelings (and he hoped hers’ as well) no longer fit into the category of “friendship”. After Chris tried to persuade Brittany to be his girlfriend the way she viewed their experiences no longer matched up with her expectations of a friendship. This made the key difference in how the experience is symbolically categorized. They decided to rename the relationship from friendship to romantic relationship and shift the criterial attributes, thereby redefining the relationship. Once Brittany realized that the actual relationship wasn’t changing, just how she was making sense of it was changing, I think her decision became a little easier. Maybe if she had been familiar with the RSI model this decision would have been a lot easier for her!

This week I met with my partner to write an outline for our paper. We came up with a number of topics to discuss and I think we have a solid foundation for our paper. While discussing some things to write about we were talking about how the CDC campaign is an example of an attention shift in the RSI model, what we weren’t sure about was if it was only an attention shift or is everything an example of power and need  shifts as well...? Other than that I think I understand everything I need to do for my paper and how to describe it using RSI terms. 

Tuesday, March 4, 2014

PR campaigns and RSI critiques

My interest has always been in Public Relations. It is what I am majoring in and it is what I want to do as a career. When reading chapter 5, the steps of an RSI critique reminded me of the RACE process we practice as PR professionals. The RACE acronym stands for research, action, communication, evaluation. This is very similar to the RSI model critique of the pre-analysis, analysis, and post-analysis process. When developing a successful PR campaign, you must first ask, “What will make people interested in this?” Much like the pre-analysis stage of naming the social intervention, to begin enacting the role of RSI critic you must first choose an intervention to analyze. Once you figure out what people are interested in you must figure out how it relates to social change. Maybe skin cancer has become a big issue lately and a sunscreen company wants to take advantage of this, then you must figure out what to emphasize. In PR usually an event or a celebrity endorser helps to draw people to the cause. 

Once you have an idea, you begin to collect data about the intervention, or research as it is referred to in the public relations (PR) process. Or as it is stated in the RSI model, “How have other scholars studied my topic?” Research allows PR professionals to see where other campaigns have gone wrong, what demographic is most interested in this product, and what objectives will best help them meet their goals of improving interaction between the company and its publics. This is where the strategies, tactics, and maneuvers of the RSI critic come into play with the “action” part of the PR process. You must locate the rhetorical artifacts that communicate the interveners intentions to determine if your objective is accessible. 

In PR, after we review the data or research and determine the communication process that will most effectively communicate our message we put it into action. In the RSI critique model, we must decide what social system to emphasize in our research. So by abstracting from experience we must decide what people will relate to the intervention and we do this for both processes. As part of enacting the role of RSI critic, the questions we are given to ask ourselves such as, “How will I share my interpretation with others?” or “Who is the audience for my analysis?” are similar to questions we as PR professionals ask ourselves when evaluating a successful campaign. Although the steps do not match up exactly the steps for developing a PR campaign are very similar to the RSI model critique of pre-analysis, analysis, and post-analysis processes.

I think I am starting to understand the terms a little more now. I think because the terms are starting to repeat more and as I begin to see them again and again in the readings they are starting to become more familiar. As they are becoming more familiar, I am starting to get a better idea of what RSI topics I can focus on in my paper. From my research I am going to come up with 10 or so ideas with my partner to cover in our paper. From these ideas will be main topics or paragraphs covered in the essay. I think this will be a good alternative to an outline and help us get a good start. 

Wednesday, February 26, 2014

The Deviance of Political Campaigns

After reading this weeks chapter, the terms and examples used reminded me of political elections, specifically, the campaign process. When I considered it, candidates entire campaigns are structured around maneuvers, tactics, and strategies. In the most general sense, their objective and strategy is to get elected to the office of their choosing and defeat their opponent. They bring about strategic results by using specific tactics that will help further their agenda. Some tactics used by politicians are commercials, campaign tours, pamphlets, going door-to-door, rally’s, and signs. The list goes on but these are some of the most common tactics I recognized. 

I also noticed the concept of deviance in political campaigns. Candidate A tries to shift attention away from Candidate B’s positive name that he is honest and trustworthy and shift attention towards the interpretation that this he is dishonest and untrustworthy. Candidate A does this by featuring anomalies in Candidate B’s honest and trustworthy naming pattern. This is a strategy commonly carried out by tactics like negative campaign commercials and newspaper articles. In order to do this effectively, Candidate A must also mask anomalies in Candidate B’s honest and trustworthy naming pattern. This can cause a vicious cycle of “smear campaigns”.

I received feedback for my critical analysis proposal yesterday. After looking over my paper and the critique I definitely need to work on my APA style for citations. I think I understand how to structure the paper in APA, but for citations I am used to MLA. In order to fix this problem and ensure a better grade for the next graded assignment, which is the first draft, I think I am going to go to the writing center in the library to have them educate me about correct APA citation style and edit my mistakes. The only other thing I am concerned about is my understanding of the terms. I am struggling to relate some of the terms in the book to real life situations, or in the case of this paper, The CDC’s intervention campaign against smoking. I think the most obvious thing to do for my paper is to focus on the maneuvers, strategies, and tactics the CDC uses to educate people about the dangers of smoking.

I find this topic very interesting because of the personal connection. I think my starting point for this essay will be to focus on the idea that the CDC is trying to highlight the anomaly's of smoking (cancer, heart attack, loss of limbs, death). I will then show that these events violate their ideological expectancy that smoking will not cause them long term damage. This campaign shows that smoking deviates from our expectations because no one expects that horrible things like this will happen to them. The CDC campaign focuses on personal stories from victims of these anomalies in order to persuade smokers to quit. I believe this demonstrates one of the tactics the CDC is using to educate people on the negative health impacts of smoking. 

Tuesday, February 18, 2014

Advocating and Attributing from Commercials

How many minutes of commercials are there on average in a one hour program? 15 minutes. And who watches just one program? According to a recent study by Statistic Brain, the average American watches 5 hours of television a day. So a little basic math, 5 episodes a day, 15 minute per episode, that’s 75 minutes of commercials a day. In just one week the average American sees almost 9 hours of commercials! In just one week! There are commercials for many different things, some for a new brand of sneakers or shampoo, some for a new movie, even some for things like yogurt or cotton. What do all of these commercials have in common? They are all trying to persuade you to do something, whether its buy their product or watch their show, they all are using advertisements to advocate their needs to you. 

This creates social interventions. The company advocates by communicating their need for their product or service to be consumed. They do this by attributing to the viewer why they simply cannot live without this product. We as viewers can accept or deny attributions by choosing to consume it or not. For example, Axe makes commercials targeted at young boys that try to persuade them to by their body spray by featuring beautiful women in their commercials that are simply unable to resist this body spray. Axe attributes to young boys that if they buy this body spray, women will find them irresistible as well. They even have a threat in some of their commercials that show a boy being ignored if he is not wearing Axe body spray. By cooperating in their exchange (the boy attributing the need in hopes of being “irresistible” and Axe being reliant on consumers to purchase their product) they have created a reciprocal relationship. 

Today my partner and I wrote the proposal for our critical essay. We decided to write about anti smoking commercials as a social intervention. It is a social intervention because it encourages social change by using the “threat” of health risks to discourage people from smoking or to persuade them to quit smoking. Some of the videos we watched were quite graphic and it was extremely uncomfortable to watch the effects smoking can have on the body. As someone who smoked for a brief period of time, I can say with absolute confidence that I will never smoke again. This is one of the reasons I think it was such a successful intervention campaign. It impacted both me and my partner personally to eliminate smoking in our lives and the lives of people close to us. We watched many of the commercials produced by this CDC campaign and we are also going to read scholarly articles and journals to make sure our research is credible. 

Sunday, February 16, 2014

Anti-Smoking Interventions

The hardest thing about writing this blog is coming up with my topic. When I think about an intervention I think about persuasion. Theres so many persuasive pieces out there it can’t be that hard to think of one! I asked myself what is one of the biggest “persuasion campaigns” on television and my first thought was anti-smoking campaigns. Millions of dollars are spent every year on commercials and magazine advertisements to try and convince people to quit smoking. I would even guess that a comparable if not greater amount of money is spent trying to convince people to quit smoking than is spent trying to market and sell cigarettes. I can think of no other market that just as much money is spent trying to prevent purchases as is spent trying to encourage purposes. 

This really makes for an interesting scenario. When I thought about how much money is spent trying to market both these options (smoking and quitting smoking) I started to wonder. Are they effective? And which one is more effective? I found a study that stated that the source of anti smoking ads influences their effectiveness. So for instance, ads funded by states or private foundations are found to be the most effective. This leads me to believe that it matters to people how credible the intervener is. This goes along with Aristotle’s theory of persuasion that the ethos, or ethical appeal of the speaker is important to the audience. So no matter how persuasive the advertisement is, it may not encourage change if the person the ad is directed at does not think the source is credible. 

I also found an article that discussed a study of how effective the amount of anti-smoking ads were. As the number of ads in a given area increased, the number of smokers decreased. This was true for all up to a certain amount of ads, once there was too many ads, the amount of smokers actually started to increased. This led the researchers to believe that after a certain amount the viewers started to tune out the ads. The intervention was not effective for them because they were not using all of their senses and they abstracted in their environment to form sensory and symbolic categories, they blocked out these ads. 

I am going to work with a partner for the paper. We have decided to write about an advertising campaign for our topic. I think this is a really good thing for both of us because we are PR majors and this is something were both interested in. We are meeting after class on Tuesday to write the proposal paper so we can get a little more information in class about what is expected. After writing this blog post I think it might be interesting to write about anti-smoking commercials for my paper. There is certainly a wide range of options to choose from and lots of information about it. I am going to do some research on it and see if it would be feasible to write my paper on this subject. 

Sunday, February 9, 2014

The Answer Was Right in Front of Me...

         I came across a story in an excerpt from one of my books this morning. Instead of poorly retelling it I have attached a picture of the story. Please read before continuing to read my post. 




Are you as confused as I was? How could this boy be the surgeons son? I read the story again. Yes, I was correct, the father died on the way to the hospital. How is this possible? I knew the answer was right in front of me, I was sure this was one of those riddles I would feel very silly after learning the answer. I was correct! I read on in the text for the answer. I never once considered that the surgeon could be the boys mother!

The answer was given to me very clearly, the surgeon said boy was “my son” and I knew the father had died on the way to the hospital. Shouldn’t that immediately tell me that the surgeon was the boys mother? No, because I had default assumptions, which means we assume that the way things are is the way they ought to be. I named the doctor as a male because there was no reference to the doctors gender and most surgeons are men so I automatically assumed the doctor was a male. Even though there was no reason to think this, my mind was stuck with preconceived notions. Furthermore, the author even went on to say that he should have figured it out because his daughter was a surgeon! He was blatantly giving me the answer and I didn’t catch it because I had automatically named the doctor as a man. Once I knew the real identity of the mother, it completely changed the entire scenario for me.

I was looking over the evaluation for the proposal paper and it says the paper needs to be done in APA style so I will need to brush up on that, I am used to MLA format. I was also wondering how many citations / resources I will need to use for the paper (and if there needs to be more for the actual paper, I would assume so). I know that I will definitely use the text and whatever film or article my group chooses but what other sources would be appropriate? I also need to become more familiar with the RSI model, but the assignment sheet says chapter 5 elaborates on this so I will try to read that as soon as possible so I can get started on this paper. 

Today in class we decided to work as groups, right now there is four of us so I’m not sure if we will be working in one group or two. We exchanged phone numbers and we are going to each come up with three ideas each and we are going to vote on one we all agree upon. Our ideas can be articles, documentaries, books, advertising campaigns, or any other persuasive piece that fits the definition of an intervention. I am going to use my idea I discussed in my last blog and go on Netflix and find documentaries because I think that will give us the most information to pull from. It sounds like the others are moving more towards an advertisement, I just worry we will not have enough information to work with to write a 15 page paper. 

Tuesday, February 4, 2014

Groundhog's Day- An Intervention

To kick off this blog I’m going to be taking baby steps this week by discussing an article we looked at in class, “Why groundhogs day should be outlawed” by Tom Purcell.  http://townhall.com/columnists/tompurcell/2014/02/02/why-groundhog-day-should-be-outlawed-n1788360 Because the RSI model is so new and foreign to me I thought I would start with a piece I am a little more familiar with. 

So far we have learned that an intervention is a communication act that attempts to encourage or discourage change. This article is an example of an intervention because Tom is trying to persuade us to avoid Groundhog’s Day because it is “guilty of numerous offenses”. He states that it is biased against women by keeping them out of leadership positions that manage and oversee Groundhog’s Day. It is also un-American because it is a Christian event and we are not following the “American tradition of separating church and state.” The best one by far though, is that Phil (the groundhog) has a harem, and he is provided with three female companions around the clock. Did I mention this article is satirical?

His choice of words is what would prompt readers to avoid this “primitive ritual”. Everything he says, although exaggerated, is negative. He proposes the renaming of Groundhog’s day to Groundshrub’s day by replacing the poor captive groundhog with a less offensive item such as a tree or a shrub. Everything about this article makes it very clear that he is trying to persuade his audience that Groundhog’s day must be stopped. I never considered the RSI model while viewing persuasive pieces but it makes me view them in a completely new way. 

For the paper I have started preparing for the first step of the process, the proposal paper. I have talked to some of the people in the group I sit with in class and I think that we might break off into two or three groups and work on the paper together. That being said, I won’t be able to finalize a topic until I finalize a group. Working independently right now I think one of the simplest and most effective things would be to write a paper on a documentary or short film. I believe Netflix might even have a whole section filled with different possibilities of movies to choose from. 

I think a documentary would be an excellent idea for a persuasive piece because it is longer and more in-depth than an article. It would give us much more material to pull from. After my group has been finalized, I think it would be a good idea for each of us to research independently and come up with a list of no more than 5 options to consider as our intervention topic and vote on the best one. This way, it will be mutually agreed upon. I don’t believe it will be very difficult to find an example of an intervention that we all find interesting, most persuasive pieces speak to a certain audience and I think we will find one we all like.